Idea 2

Top

Web Home Page
Up to Parent Page       

"E Pluribus Unum"

bulletA well-chosen motto can draw people together to act in harmony despite their individual differences.  One phrase seems "just right" for this purpose because it is inclusive and impartial.

Elaboration

A motto is a statement of goals or ideals, or a maxim adopted as a principle of behavior.  Youngsters readily develop a sense of what it means to "live up to your motto."  Thus,  there is perhaps no better platform on which to ground your neutrality efforts regarding religion than the original motto of the nation:  E Pluribus Unum.  

E Pluribus Unum is a Latin phrase for "Out of Many—One" or "One Whole from Many Parts."  The meaning pertains to the fusing of a group of individual political units into a single federal state.  The context, in our case, was the welding together of the original thirteen colonies into thirteen states of a nation.

 The first national motto—E Pluribus Unum—served the United States for 175 years.  The second motto— "In God We Trust"—has been in use for 45 years. The latter replaced the original in 1956, at the height of the cold war with the Soviet Union.  The story of the nation's two mottos is told in many places.  One source for information is www.religioustolerance.org/nat_mott.htm, which has rather lengthy material contrasting the original national motto with its replacement.

Side note: The present slogan, In God We Trust, is discomfiting for many citizens.  Although it has been judged constitutional as a promoter of national patriotism and is admired by many, it does not work as a construct for bridging all differences and fully unifying people. Despite its many admirers, the slogan exacerbates a problematic situation.  Its neglect of all those persons whose religious and nonreligious worldviews do not include a monotheistic construct seriously marginalizes these citizens. The original U.S. motto—E Pluribus Unum—has no such drawbacks.  It presents a solid building block for advancing religious pluralism and offers a level playing field for everyone.

The original U.S. motto, E Pluribus Unum, was (and remains) a key element of the Great Seal of the United States.  It is the motto of interest here, and its history is worth noting.  Three of the founding fathers—John Adams, Benjamin Franklin, and Thomas Jefferson—were assigned by Congress to come up with a design for a "Great Seal" for the nation.  This committee received its task assignment on an auspicious date—July 4, 1776. They submitted a design in August that contained the motto, "E Pluribus Unum," but that failed to meet Congress's approval and only after several designs and several years did the project reach fruition.  The approved design, submitted by the Secretary of Congress in June, 1782, combined several elements—an eagle with shield, olive branch, and arrows—with the original E Pluribus Unum motto (on a scroll held in the eagle's beak).

For your classroom microcosm, the "one from many" phrase has practical meaning beyond that of "one nation out of many states".  In our increasingly heterogeneous nation, another meaning is appropriate: "one nation out of its many citizens.  This notion depicts the melding of a diverse U.S. citizenry into a whole nation under a single constitution.  Acknowledging that each citizen will have his/her personal worldview beliefs, you can focus on the expectation that all citizens can and will work together in striving to sustain national ideals.

In your classroom, where a group of students is a "nation" of "citizens," the ideal of neutrality permits no "caste system" by worldview.  It places all the youngsters on a level playing field.  

Any slogan you use to build cohesion within your classroom needs to be manifestly fair to all.  E Pluribus Unum meets that criterion.

Idea 1 "Classroom as a Microcosm"Back in a Series Next in a Series Idea 3 "Lingo Lifting"

Return to Top

Instructional Systems, 163418 Fort Sutter Station, Sacramento, CA 95816

Email: OABITAR@aol.com

Last updated 8/18/2006

OABITAR is a 501(c)(3)  non-profit educational organization.

All materials developed by Instructional Systems are copyright © 2002,3,4,5,6. Please contact I.S. to arrange for free duplication privileges.